SongTrellis
Music and Musical Know-how For You

Members
Join Now
Login

Home | How-Tos | Directory | Our Composers | The Rhythms | Play Rhythm | Rhythm Web | Tonematrix | Chord Grid | The Changes | Song Discussions | Public Ideas | SongTrellis Recommends... | Video Links | Great Performances | SongTrellis Music Editor | The Lessons | Jukebox | The Animations | Our Contributors | Latest Topics | Tunetext | Workscore Chord Entry | Chord Entry By Grid | Workscore Composer | Music Tool Lore | Harmonic Interval Palette | Harmony Projects | Search | Video Demonstrations | Playlists | What's a Songtrellis? | FAQ | Feedback

Author Gary Myers
Posted 12/18/07; 10:55:46 PM
Topic At Last
Msg# 5375 (in response to 2335)
Prev/Next 5374/5376
Reads 1417

1. I prefer a 6th to a maj7 on bar 1 (and in a couple of other spots) where the melody is a long "do". I think nearly all singers (myself included) would not like the minor 2nd disonance with a note they are holding.

2. The spelled out C7alt (in a few places) is missing the E note,  one of the most important notes in the chord. (In fact the spelled out chord turns out to be Abadd9/C).

3. I dislike the "alt" designation anyway, as I've never understood it to pertain to a specific alteration. I don't recall even seeing it used except in very old fake books, which are often incomplete and/or inaccurate. Since the alterations shown in that specific chord are Ab and Eb, why not call it C7+ (#9) ?

4. The 2 spots in the bridge (or B section) that show Gm-G7 are normally Dm7-G7. While the former does work, I've never heard it played that way, and it forsakes the ii-V-I that is normally there. The bridge is basically: ii-V-I, then ii-V-i in the key of iii, then ii-V-I in the key of V. For the last 1/2 of the bridge, I like: Dm7-G7 | Cmaj7 - C#dim | Dm7- G7 | Gm7-C7 ||


There are responses to this message:
blog comments powered by Disqus

Please join our community at SongTrellis. Our contributors welcome your comments, suggestions and requests. As soon as you join the site (or login if you are a member) a response form will appear here.




Last update: Tuesday, December 18, 2007 at 10:55 PM.